A Review in the Spring 1997 Issue
Rare Books & Manuscripts Librarianship


Arbour, Keith. Canvassing Books, Sample Books, and Subscription Publishers' Ephemera 1833–1951 in the Collection of Michael Zinman. Ardsley, New York: The Haydn Foundation for the Cultural Arts, 1996. xxiv, 10 ff. illustrations, xxv–xxviii; pp. 1–458 bibliography; pp. [459]–517 indices. $90.00 ISBN 0-937704-08-3.

    Some bibliographies are wished for years, even generations, before they appear; then there are those for which few think to wish, but which, when they appear, are met by an excited intake of breath and delighted thanks for having opened new vistas of collecting, scholarship, and access to materials already in collections but often under- or miscatalogued because misunderstood. One of these latter, welcomed surprises is Keith Arbour's meticulous bibliography describing and usefully cross-indexing over 1780 examples of the elaborate "canvassing outfits" carried by the door-to-door book peddlers who both served and pestered the reading citizenry of 19th-century America. There have been no uniform cataloguing conventions for these, even where librarians have tried to describe them with systematic care; Arbour essentially had to invent his methodology. All described items are from the evocative collection of private collector Michael Zinman, which enfolds another large collection built over many years by bookseller Robert Seymour. [Note, 1998: This collection now resides and is available for study in the Special Collections Department of the University of Pennsylvania.]

    Typical outfits included the order forms and other paraphernalia establishing and forwarding the business connection between the canvassing agent and his publisher-employer, plus, either integrally as part of a "canvassing book" or separately as a "sample book," a mini-version of the book being sold that had been specifically designed for an agent's show-and-tell—bearing, usually, the volume's title-page, table of contents, and most thrilling illustrations and "bits" (sometimes from proofs or early states), with standard and perhaps optional binding samples glued to the pastedowns. (Each entry in Arbour's main, alphabetical-by-author listing tells what is present in the volume described, including always a note on its binding, with the indices providing access by publisher, publication place, copyright holder, title, and language.) Also present might be "bound-in leaves of recommendations, advertisements, and conditions of sale, tipped-in sales speech slips, handbills, and broadside puffs, loosely inserted leaflets and pamphlets of sales advice, and leaves and chits of manuscript additions solicited by agents from their territories' influential citizens" (xi). Some canvassing books still contain the agents' manuscript subscription lists, telling who bought the books so enticingly flourished. Thus the outfits and Arbour's descriptions of them present a complex array of information found absolutely nowhere else about what 19th-century American book publishers thought they were doing, and for whom, and why they thought their "market" might actually want or be brought to want what they were selling.

    Moreover, the books canvassers offered were of the sort that by and large did not "make" Wright and BAL and so are themselves understudied—yet they are what millions of Americans read and wanted to read; they are books they were proud to own. The cliché assuming Victorians' fascinated, reverential curiosity about Great Men is supported: Titles beginning Life, Lives, or Memoirs (135) outnumber all other such constellations; military giants, naval heroes, patriotic women, statesmen, and evangelists, along with notable villains, "hot" celebrities, and Queen Victoria herself all have their many volumes. Another 70 titles begin, History: American, sacred, or "world," the spectacle and sweep of history enchanted our ancestors. Listed are books in French, German, and Scandinavian languages as well as English. There are children's books, conduct books, song books, and Civil War reminiscences; lavishly illustrated works on newly knowable exotic peoples and places; books on floods, fires, earthquakes, tidal waves, and other sensational disasters; books on moral philosophy, the fine points of etiquette, and elocution; and books on health and home medicine for man, woman, child, and beast. There are romances, poetry, and joke books; fairy tales and cookbooks and books preaching temperance; books charting study courses on science, law, and the Bible; books on horse-training, how to make money, and "the American Negro in the Great World War." USA Today did not invent the convention of telling "us" what "we" think, do, or believe—52 titles begin, Our, e.g., Our Baby Darlings, Our Country in Peace and War, Our Faith and Its Defenders, Our Feathered Friends, Our Home Doctor, Our Islands and Their People; Our Martyred Presidents, Our Social Manual for All Occasions, Our Wild Indians, Our Wonderful Progress. Only five titles begin, My—and four of them are for children.

    At a lively seminar headed by Arbour this Spring [1997] at the University of Pennsylvania, librarians from a number of institutions and scholars of a number of disciplines all bubbled with new thoughts and possible projects based on the kinds of materials exhibited as explorable artifacts in this bibliography. The collection described was formed in New England: What might have been the results, and the suggestions, had it been formed west of Iowa? What was the appeal of the frequently suggested sales pitch, "Not to be bought in any store?" These books were to be touted as "cheap"—but were they? A seminar attendee knew of a library-held archive of one book agent's records, but clearly this would be exceptional: How much can be known about the men and women who served as canvassers? Were male and female agents recruited differently, and were they encouraged by the sales advice to sell differently? Science-oriented scholars asked about scientific and medical volumes represented; others wanted to know the nature of the evangelical, women's, children's, or ethnically directed items. Historians of business were interested in the hub-and-hinterland networks suggested by variant title-pages recorded. Printing specialists wondered what could be learned of the order and time-table of book printing processes from the various states of texts shown in sample books—for not all sample books came off the presses at the same stage in their full books' publications. Students of binding wanted to know, were all sample bindings actually produced, and were bindings ever revised in light of the "market research" submitted to the publishers by their canvassers? Some participants were knowledgeable about subscription publishing and canvassing/sample books while some had never heard of either before the announcement of the seminar; but all were intrigued by the possibilities that the books treated to Arbour's detailed, precise, and accurate descriptions offered their work.

    Arbour's introduction reminds us that canvassing agents' subscription sales represented the only way books got to many rural Americans, and that they were a surprisingly prominent source of books for urban Americans as well, especially in poor and ethnic communities where bookstores were few. The "demo" books he describes and the complete books they prefigured offer a rich lode to the whole variegated range of scholars mining American cultural history and values. For if Whitman had written, "I see America reading," these would have been the books he envisioned in its eager hands.

— By PRB&M Partner Cynthy Buffington


Go Back to Sample Books

  E-MAIL US   |   GO (BACK) TO TOPIC/INTEREST TABLE   |   PRB&M HOME

All material © 2010
The Philadelphia Rare Books & Manuscripts Company